Why the people behind the Vagenda shouldn’t have apologised for a dog burnt to death

This is the Vagenda. It’s Wikipedia article describes itself as this:

 The editors stated: “the women’s press is a large hadron collider of bullshit and that something needed to be done”. Cosslett describes The Vagenda as “a media watchdog with a feminist angle”

Yesterday the pair behind the Vagenda, Holly Baxter and Rhiannon Lucy Cosslett had a pair of articles in The Guardian. Cosslett wrote a piece where she discussed how career advisors were useless and she agreed with Micheal Gove, while Baxter wrote a piece saying that a rich man can happily use Kickstarter to fund their vanity project, but a musician,Dev Hynes, who saw his home burn down which included his work, most of his possessions and his puppy and saw his girlfriend’s mother start a crowdfund to help him was essentially a step too far.

Both articles are hateful, despicable examples of the worst sort of vile clickbait journalism that sites like Vagenda use, and papers desperate for clicks (as The Guardian is) pump out. This has been the case for the last few years, but yesterday saw a double whammy which dragged the reputation of The Guardian well and truly in the gutter as not only is the position of mocking crowdfunding a tad hypocritical from people who benefited from it themselves, but it makes the position of ‘journalist’ trival.

Cosslett could have researched her piece. She instead decided to use anecdotal evidence to say it was the case for everyone. Baxter could have Tweeted or contacted Hynes to find out what was going on. She didn’t as that would have involved spending some time researching the piece and also, that might have challenged her opinions, which she clearly feels outweigh anything else.

The problem is that it’s all fine and well getting bloggers to fill in for journalists, but when bloggers who only know how to get clicks suddenly talk about issues that involves research, or even a little bit of decency then it fails to be anything but essentially trolling the public.I do think however they don’t need to apologise because any apology is utterly worthless as they mean what they say, otherwise they wouldn’t have written it in the first place.

You do have to question why The Guardian continues to employ the pair, but then again they get the clicks but when you have Cheryl Cole being on the moral high ground then you’ve got to question their future.

There’s a lot online about this, especially on Twitter but the best summary of it is Holy Moly’s (and yes, when they have the moral high ground you’re really fucked) account here.

4 thoughts on “Why the people behind the Vagenda shouldn’t have apologised for a dog burnt to death

  1. I’ve been surprised by the amount of recoil this article has achieved and the amount (and type) of people that have been reprimanding it. Rightly so though, it was a crass and tasteless piece of ‘journalism’ that tried to rise bigger issues of which Baxter appeared completely ignorant of, generally never rising above ill-timed and misinformed ‘aren’t I controversial’ claptrap, all topped off with a tabloid-level headline. It also certainly didn’t help that Dev Hynes is possibly one of the nicest and unassuming deities out there and his following are loyal and, I must say, rather fierce dragqueens.

    Like

  2. I didn’t really know Hynes before this piece Baxter wrote, but he’s conducted himself fantastically over this tabloid piece of trash journalism from someone who really should be ashamed of themselves.

    Also, had this been printed in the Mail, the Guardian would have had a week at least of articles describing how awful it and it’s author was. The way the Guardian has brushed this under the carpet is disgusting.

    Like

  3. Pingback: 2013-That Was the Year That Was | My Little Underground

  4. Pingback: A few things about The Last Alan Moore Interview? | My Little Underground

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.