My top 20 Comic Book films-4-American Splendor

I did my top 20 horror and SF films last year, and found doing the lists to be more fun than expected, so in a massive bit of logic here’s my top 20 films adapted or inspired from comics. I need to point out I mean comics, not ‘superhero comics’ which is a lazy, and incorrect way to describe a wonderfully varied medium and it’d also cut out some bloody good films!

Previously, in this list at #20, X Men19The Crow18Heavy Metal, 17, Spider Man ,16The Avengers, 15Danger: Diabolik, 14The Dark Knight Trilogy , 13A History of Violence12Kick Ass , 11,Spider Man 2 , 10, Barbarella9, Batman Returns 8, X Men 2, 7, Dredd, 6Batman and 5, Akira.

My fourth favourite comic book film is one a lot of comic book fans have probably not seen. It’s the film adaptation of Harvey Pekar’s American Splendor.


I first came across the American Splendor comic at some point in the mid 1980’s when I was expanding my comic knowledge and tastes beyond men in tights hitting each other while women with unfeasible bosoms look on in moist awe.

Really it was an expanding love of Robert Crumb’s work that drew me to Pekar’s work though initially I thought it was tedious and boring, then I actually read it. Once I had I realised that Pekar was telling the sory of a working class man in a post-industrial city trying to make a life for himself. It’s exactly the sort of thing comics should be doing more of because the majority of voices in any sort of comic tends to be the white middle class, or in superhero comics you’ve got heroes being made out of billionaires and arms dealers.

Pekar was real and honest, often to a degree which was painful to read, or funny, or sad, or interesting. He was the guy in the pub who you’d normally avoid but when you actually made the effort to speak to him you discovered fantastic new things about life and humanity from another perspective. This for me was the joy of American Splendor, so when I hear a film was on it’s way I was apprehensive to say the least as this could quite easily have been a total disaster.

Luckily it wasn’t, or rather luck had little to do with it as opposed to the casting of Paul Giamatti who captured Pekar’s essence perfectly, and although he and Hope Davis (who plays Pekar’s third wife, Joyce Brabner) are a little bit too smooth round the edges, the film deals with this by having the real Pakar and Brabner as part of the film’s narrative (not to mention a lot of other real people like Pekar and Brabner’s step-daughter Danielle Batone, and their friend Toby Radloff) so the film isn’t just a dramatisation of Pekar’s life, but a documentary as well as a meta-commentary on the entire process.

American Splendor is a unique, funny, sometime challenging work that isn’t just better than what most people were expecting, but surpassed it. It’s a fantastic film that should be enjoyed by a wider audience because it deserves it.

Next time, are you ready? Nananananana…….

4 thoughts on “My top 20 Comic Book films-4-American Splendor

  1. yeah dude, I just saw this movie for the first time last week. fucking mind-blowing. the “meta-commentary”, as you put it, seriously hurt my brain–but in a good way.


  2. Pingback: My top 20 Comic Book films-3-Batman: The Movie | My Little Underground

  3. Pingback: My top 20 Comic Book films-2-Ghost World | My Little Underground

  4. Pingback: My top 20 Comic Book films-1-Superman: The Movie | My Little Underground

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.