A totally unexpected reappraisal of Justice League

Yesterday I activated my free month of Amazon Prime to take in Picard, the new Star Trek series. That was excellent and I especially loved the subtle Brexit reference, but that’s for another day. After that I had a look at what Amazon offered, and had Zack Snyder’s Justice League film recommended to me, but I’d found the film a mess not to mention a chore to get through when I’d seen it the only time a few years back. I thought I’d give it a few minutes to see if things had changed expecting to stop and have an early night.

And I liked it lots more than I did previously.

justiceleague

Maybe some distance has passed, and although the issues still stand it really is more enjoyable than a number of other superhero films, plus it has an actual sense of a directorial vision which the Marvel films, on the whole, have lost.  Sure, the scenes shot by Joss Whedon stand out a mile, the villain is badly done, the script has gaping holes, and that CGI lip is an awful bit of work to appear in a big-budget Hollywood film.

However, the League themselves are actually interesting. Affleck’s Batman is an interesting portrayal of an older man who’d lost his way finding redemption. Gal Gadot’s Wonder Woman is the standout star character of the DCEU and should be its bedrock as Iron Man was for Marvel. While Jason Mamoa’s Aquaman and Ezra Miller’s Flash have a genuine spark on screen. Hell, even Cyborg seemed less tokenistic this time round.  The big loser here is Henry Cavill and his Clark Kent/Kal El/Superman as once he’s allowed to play Superman not as a brooding Emo type, but actually as Superman, he’s a revelation.

It’s a flawed experiment and yes, I’d be interested in seeing what a full ‘Snyder cut’ would look like because again, there’s a bland generic quality creeping in to the point you couldn’t tell who directed one Marvel film to another. With this it is pretty clear it’s Snyder’s vision. You may not like it, but there’s a clear vision which makes the Whedon footage clash so badly, and also, there’s a bit of irony as the Marvel template is based on what Whedon did with the first two Avengers films.

It is unlikely DC/Warners will do a Justice League film again in some time, which  is a shame as it’d be good to see this group together again but in a film free of studio meddling.

But there you go, I never thought I’d write any of that but it shows opinions do change…

What I thought of Crisis on Infinite Earths

Imagine trying to do Avengers: Endgame on a budget akin to Scarlet Johansen’s hairdresser? That’ll be the CW’s version of Marv Wolfman and George Perez’s comic Crisis on Infinite Earths.

coieposter

A five-part series designed to partly clean up issues with the CW’s Arrowverse and to act as this year’s big crossover event to end all events. Overall it manages to just hold together, and just work though the problem as usual with the Arrowverse programmes is the budget holds back the ambition so what should be a cosmic level event (something Marvel have shied off adapting fully as yet) comes over as sometimes small, and in the case of episode two, slow and stretched.

The other problem is that when it needs action we get exposition, or worse, exposition from people standing round the set looking a bit stiff. However the producers clearly love the source material, and they clearly love what they’re doing so for all the multiple flaws they manage just about to live up to this fan made poster from a few years back.

crisis-on-infinite-earths-fan-poster

Crisis works because they realise the entire thing is daft, and they know that superhero comics are essentially melodramas so they embrace that, so we have all the usual aspects of a CW show mixed with these overaught moments of superhero comics, mixed with possibly the biggest, and first, comic book mega-crossover.

coieposter2

They manage to tie every DC TV series to the Arrowverse bar Lynda Carter’s Wonder Woman series and the Shazam! series from the 70’s due mainly to the reason that Warners have successful film versions but remarkably, everything else did make an appearance from the Titans, to Tom Welling from Smallville, Brandon Routh reprising his role as Superman which means the Christopher Reeve films are canon, through to the surprise cameo of Ezra Miller as the DC film version of The Flash.

I enjoyed the entire crossover a lot, with that Miller cameo especially making me like Miller’s depiction of my favourite superhero more than I did. Yeah, some of it is awful, cheap and badly acted/written at times but this is soap opera and it’s also great entertainment which has the good guys beating the baddies which in 2020 is a great message to send out.

My last fanboy wish would be they repay the cameo and bring in the TV Flash for the film due sometime in the next few years, but that can’t happen can it?

The DC Comics 50th anniversary party

Back in 1984 DC Comics had it’s 50th anniversary which was an historic turning point, as DC finally turned into a company that could take Marvel on. 1984-5 is a serious time of transition just as the Bronze Age closes and the modern era starts and this video is the sort of video they used to send out to comic shops back in the day but mainly what would happen is they’d be watched once, then end up gathering dust somewhere.

What’s great about this is the foreshadowing of the new era to come. Alan Moore, Alan Davies, and Dave Gibbons get namechecked, you get to see Julie Schwartz and Dick Giordano, plus a half-cut Joe Orlando. IT really is a wonderful bit of history.

Enjoy.

What I thought of Batman: City of Bane

Tom King’s run on Batman has been controversial to say the least, but reading it as a whole (all 85 issues of it) will throw up problems. For example, the first issue of Batman: Rebirth is awful, awful stuff read now, and not even average as I thought at the time. However over the run, King gets to redefine not just Batman, but Catwoman and Bane in a way that future writers now have more to play with which is why it depressingly looks as if it’ll be ignored or skimmed over in future.

King’s entire run is essentially building up to City of Bane, a ten-part story that wraps everything up, and there’s a lot to wrap up.

batman75

Over the course of King’s run, we’ve seen Bane scheme to destroy Batman once and for all. As this storyline starts, Bruce Wayne has been broken. Defeated by his father Thomas, the Batman of the Flashpoint reality saved by the Reverse Flash and Bane, Bruce Wayne is expelled from Gotham leaving it under the control of Batman’s rogue gallery, who are themselves controlled by Bane thanks to the Psycho Pirate who can control anyone.

City of Bane details Batman and Catwoman taking Gotham City back from Bane and the villians. There’s lots of fighting, and lots and lots of characters standing on rooftops spouting exposition done in the most tedious ways, but it is a way to work out what Batman is by pitting him against a twisted shadow in the shape of Thomas Wayne. Eventually of course Batman and Catwoman defeat Bane and Thomas, while expressing their love for each other, which is just one of the way King changes the Batman dynamic along with the murder of Alfred by Bane.

batman80

You rarely get runs of 85 issues or more by a writer these days. Most go in for 12-24 issues, enough for a trade or two, tell a story and get out so King being allowed the time to tell his story is admirable of DC. Though sales figures probably dictated that King curbed his planned 100 issue run, and even with the 85 issues there’s a hell of a lot of padding.

King’s problem is his storytelling is sometimes poor for superhero comics, so instead of dynamic, exciting pages which move the action on there are just pages at times of characters standing around talking spouting exposition for panel after panel.  Rob Leifeld of all people pulled up this point on Twitter the other day.

liofeldtweet

And you know, Liefeld has a point. Superhero comics have swung so far towards cramming pages full of dialogue, they’ve forgotten they’re comics, so storytelling is being lost because writers are forgetting, or are unable, to trust artists to let the story be told by pictures. King would be a better writer if he wasn’t trying to be a third-generation Alan Moore or Neil Gaiman.batman85

King though has done something amazing in today’s climate which is produce a vision for one of DC’s big money-earners which wasn’t just pandering to a decreasing hardcore of fans who see Batman as a flawless character who can do anything. King resets Batman as a flawed character but now accepting his limits but knows he has support when he needs it. He’s become a bit more human by being allowed to love.

An 85 issue run is an achievement and although King’s run won’t have changed comics for any much the better or worse, he’s told a Batman story at times massively entertaining, at times awful and at times frustrating but it has been interesting which Batman in the comics hasn’t been for some time now. King now moves onto other things, including helping adapt Jack Kirby’s New Gods for the screen so his comics work could take second place to his new career in film but he’s now a writer who is one to keep an eye on just in case le learns to curb his faults and become a vastly better one.

A tour round Sparta Press in 1977-an amazing bit of comic book history

The internet can still be a wonderful thing. The bit of footage I’m posting here is of a tour round Spartan Press in 1977, which to most people sounds incredibly boring but to comic book fans above a certain age especially, it’s the Mecca of comic books as this is where nearly every American comic book was printed for decades.

When I worked for Neptune Distribution in the 80’s and early 90s I was totally familiar with Sparta, as we’d get their boxes all the time. For us in the UK, this would be a Friday when we’d get our shipment from the US before picking them for shops across the UK. Many a week would end up with me down the pub covered in newsprint, but DC Comics and Marvel moved more and more of their titles to other printers who could do better justice to the art in their titles. The problem with Sparta Press is their comics are wonderfully bits of nostalgia but cheap newsprint fades with time, so take say, a Daredevil comic drawn by Frank Miller in the late 70s and its likely to look dull and faded. Better printing stock and techniques made Sparta obsolete.

So to have this video pop up in my recommendations is a joy. This is deep pop culture history so enjoy…

The genius of Robert Crumb

First time I saw any of Robert Crumb’s work I was very young and had an instant negative reaction to it. It was, to me then, utterly repulsive but I was used to superhero comics and nothing more challenging than the best of that genre. I must have been around 9 or so because shortly after 2000AD came out, and it acted like a comics education as I expanded my tastes to the point a few years later that I read more Crumb, and this time saw the genius in his work.

Some of it was still repulsive, some of it would come these days with ALL the trigger warnings one can get on today’s ‘woke’ culture, but Crumb tells truths and sometimes it hurts to see people tell the truth. I suppose this is why I grew more and more into Crumb’s work as it truly is comics meant to be read by adults with an open, critical mind.

Interviews with Crumb are fascinating things.Over the Christmas holidays, a new one emerged and the interview is a wonderful thing from a man now able to look back at a long career and still tell truths. Have a look and see someone who still struggles with some of the work he’s done, and sometimes doesn’t care because that’s how it should be.

So, enjoy and go search out Crumb’s work. It will be the most extraordinary, often challenging, work you’ll ever read.

End of the decade

We’re nearly at the end of a decade many of us are glad to see the end of. It’s often said the second decade of a century marks how the rest of that century more or less goes, and if the last one is anything to go by then we won’t hit the end of this century, but after the relatively quiet 90’s and troubled 00’s we hit the decade where things start to solidify which means we’re in the middle of a dystopia what with Brexit, Trump, climate change, the destruction of modern culture, the death of facts and critical thinking and many, many more.

Take my pet topic, comics. A decade ago the comics industry in the UK was suffering thanks to the recession. The annual big convention in Bristol, London or anywhere had died and things looked bleak. The Marvel films kicked it all into overdrive though so that now a decade later the UK can’t move for ‘comic conventions’, which sadly most have nothing to do with comics.

360_a9726f2025d6cfdf88bd9441d3051161

Yet comics are in a position of cultural dominance like never before as the culture of 2019 shows compared to 2009 where frankly, most of us were thinking mainly of keeping our jobs. Today we’re entering something new for a generation who’ve spent the last decade knowing things were the norm, but having lived through many a recession what comes next endangers every industry.

What I’m talking about is Brexit. We’re about to face what it’s like to be a small country outwith of all the planet’s huge trading blocs and hey, 99% of the world think we’re utterly fucking insane. We live in the era of the liar, the cheat,the strongman who never backs down even though they are horrifyingly wrong because they don’t want to look weak. Propelled by the internet which a decade ago was still mainly a curated space but is now open war encouraged by a handful of massive corporations who have turned our lives into tradeable commodities to sell to other massive corporations. Assuming the planet doesn’t fry or freeze we have no idea where the next decade ends but for many of us it’ll end badly.

Of course things might improve but not before something awful happens on a massive scale until then let’s raise a glass to the decade which set up the horrors of the forthcoming one and hope there’s something good coming at us…